New Episodes Released Weekly!
Rochester Living Podcast

How Iron Smoke Turned a Backyard Idea Into a Fairport Destination

November 10, 2026

Key moments

Episode chapters

  1. 0:00Introduction to Tommy Brunett and Steve Brown
  2. 2:45From Rochester's music scene to Iron Smoke
  3. 7:30The backyard idea that started it all
  4. 9:20Building the Iron Smoke brand
  5. 12:30What makes Iron Smoke bourbon different
  6. 13:10Challenges facing the craft spirits industry
  7. 18:30Iron Smoke's growth in Fairport
  8. 20:05New bourbon releases and partnerships
  9. 27:00The evolution of Fairport's Cannery district
  10. 29:45Creating Iron Smoke's live music venue
  11. 35:00Helping transform the neighborhood
  12. 38:30Purchasing the distillery building
  13. 40:40What's next for Iron Smoke

Tommy Brunett was smoking ribs and drinking whiskey when the idea arrived. He had moved back from New York City in 2008, with one baby and another on the way. Somewhere between family life and backyard cooking, he started thinking about applewood smoked bourbon. That combination became the starting point for Iron Smoke, the distillery that would eventually help draw people to a once quiet corner of Fairport.

The backyard story came up when Brunett and Steve Brown joined Mark Siwiec and Corey Moran for Rochester Living Episode 261, presented by Elysian Homes. Their recent building purchase framed a conversation about a business shaped as much by music and careful spending as by whiskey.

A Partnership That Started With Music

Brown manages money for his day job, but his Rochester roots also run through the Bug Jar, which he helped found in 1991. He and Brunett knew each other from the Club Zero days and kept crossing paths in music. Brunett played in Modern English in the early 1990s, then built a career that included Universal Buzz Radio, recording bands live and working in music marketing. Brown supported Universal Buzz as an investor.

Their history mattered when Brunett approached Brown about whiskey in 2011. Brown had spirits industry connections and sought advice about the bourbon market and building a brand. They initially planned to use other producers rather than invest in their own infrastructure. Montezuma helped them get started, but they soon needed more room.

New York Grains and a Skull on the Shelf

Brunett came up with the Iron Smoke name. The partners considered label ideas that included an old locomotive before Brown suggested a skull. His years behind the Bug Jar bar informed the choice: a distinctive bottle could catch a bartender's attention and give someone a reason to try it. A pipe in the skull's mouth settled the design.

They put the same attention into what went inside. Brown says Iron Smoke gets all its grains from New York farms and grinds them the day it makes whiskey. The partners also point to New York apple cider and honey in their other products. The label was meant to get noticed, but their account of the business keeps returning to ingredients and production.

The partners say their products have earned about 120 international awards, including double gold medals. That recognition came after an idea in a backyard became a distillery making its own bourbon in Fairport. They still sound surprised by how far it has travelled.

Growing Deeper Before Growing Wider

Iron Smoke was in 12 states when the partners recorded the interview. That footprint reflects a deliberate limit, not a race toward national distribution. Brown says they wanted to concentrate on New York first. New Jersey and Florida followed, while other expansion came at partners' requests, including access to stores in Massachusetts.

The goal was to build strength in places where they already had a foothold. That approach also shaped their earliest Fairport decisions. Making bourbon came first. A tasting room could wait until the production business was established.

A Tasting Room Built to Hear the Band

They found their Fairport space in 2013 and finished building out the distillery in 2014. Brown recalls a gravel area where there was no parking lot. An accommodating landlord gave them a favorable first year lease, allowing the young company to establish itself without buying a building.

The opportunity to add a tasting room came later. They took over neighboring space and opened it in 2018, doing much of the work themselves with help from partners and tradespeople. A builder made the mahogany bar and stage. The vision was a Victorian bar with room for piano players and bands, giving local musicians somewhere to be seen and heard.

Music also influenced the construction. They brought in help to assess the acoustics and incorporated sound absorbing features into the walls, decor and drapes. Brown says that planning lets people hold a conversation on the bar side while a band plays. The room wasn't simply a place to put a stage. It was designed for listening and talking.

Fairport Neighbors Helped Build the Destination

Iron Smoke sits adjacent to the Cannery, a distinction the partners make clearly. They see the tasting room as an early draw to the area, but credit the surrounding development with making it easier for visitors to move between businesses. Boardwalks and pedestrian connections gave people more reasons to stay.

Brunett describes close relationships with their neighbors rather than competition for the same evening crowd. His example is practical: coordinating with the Village Inn so food could be available as a band finished. A night of music at Iron Smoke could carry on next door.

Buying the Building Without Losing Sight of Costs

The building purchase took roughly four years of trying. Brown says those delays kept Iron Smoke from committing millions to additional equipment before a downturn. He reports that the company reduced production from two shifts to one and describes a tougher pricing environment for craft spirits. Those are his observations about the business, not a promise that Iron Smoke is insulated from the market.

Brown credits their third partner with closely tracking where every dollar goes and says the company is cash flow positive. Buying the property still required the three partners to contribute personal funds. Village tax assistance and bank support helped make the purchase affordable, he says.

Ownership gives them more control over a place that would be difficult to leave. Roof repairs and reopening boarded facade windows are among their priorities. Additional equipment remains a later decision, tied to what the space and finances can support.

Canned Cocktails Are Still on the Drawing Board

Iron Smoke already sells bottled Manhattan and Old Fashioned cocktails. Smaller bottles and canned ready to drink options are proposed next steps, not announced launches. The partners have considered a hot honey margarita, whiskey with cola or ginger, and a possible canned boilermaker with Genesee. Brown stresses that nothing is settled.

Those ideas would require machinery, space and money. For now, the building they spent years trying to buy comes with more immediate work: repairing the roof, planning the facade and deciding what equipment belongs inside. The next product may be a can, but the next commitment is to their Fairport home.

Stay Connected

Receive Email Updates

Subscribe to our email list and receive new episode updates and more.