New Episodes Released Weekly!
Rochester Living Podcast

Inside R’s Market: Brighton’s Neighborhood Store Since 1964

November 16, 2026

Key moments

Episode chapters

  1. 0:00Introduction to R's Market
  2. 1:08A Brighton institution since 1964
  3. 3:10Getting to know the neighborhood
  4. 4:38Convenience, quality, and local products
  5. 7:06Inside the R's Market kitchen
  6. 10:02Customer favorites and homemade meals
  7. 12:53The tradition behind the store's chalkboard riddles
  8. 15:24Three products every first time customer should try
  9. 18:46Why grocery prices keep changing
  10. 22:05Balancing affordability and business costs
  11. 27:33The customers who keep R's Market going
  12. 33:25The realities of small business ownership
  13. 37:18Holiday favorites and special orders

Mary had errands to run and a knee injury that made driving difficult. Her neighbor Duffy began taking her around, and several days in a row, the 92 year old needed to stop at R’s Market. Those trips introduced Duffy and Mark Siwiec to a Brighton store they’d somehow missed. Before long, Duffy was making visits of his own.

For Mark, the difference showed up at home around 7:30 in the evening. He loves cooking but doesn’t always have time. Duffy could pick up something prepared at the market, put it in the oven and have dinner underway. That practical relief sits alongside the personal attention that keeps neighbors returning to the Monroe Avenue shop.

Bringing back the neighborhood name

R’s Market has been part of Brighton since 1964, though its history includes a closure and a change of name. Kevin Herrick, who had owned Hogan’s Hideaway, found the closed market and reopened it as the Butcher Block. Carrie Cocca had worked as a cook at Hogan’s before eventually buying the market from him.

Carrie wanted the old name back. R’s Market was what local people knew, and restoring it recognized the relationship the store already had with its neighbors. Her approach to running it follows the same logic: keep listening to the people who shop there, then give them reasons to come back.

Dinner without all the preparation

Convenience and quality guide the prepared food case. Carrie described expanding that part of the business during Covid, when people were spending more time at home. The goal was food customers could take home and put in the oven without doing all the meal preparation themselves.

The work comes from three cooks in the back, with cooking backgrounds and butchering experience among them. They develop ideas together and adjust recipes. Jesse, a former head chef at Hogan’s, contributes alongside Carrie. The small meat case keeps their selection focused on chicken, pork and beef staples, which also become the starting point for prepared dishes.

Chicken taco filling combines chicken breast with tomatoes, bell peppers, onion and garlic. A Philadelphia themed idea for the Super Bowl became Philly cheesesteak tortillas with ground beef, sharp American cheese sauce, peppers and onions. Carrie’s childhood memories of her mother’s cabbage dish helped shape a casserole after making individual cabbage rolls proved too tedious. The team added its own adjustments.

Individual chicken pot pies have their own following. Carrie described customers asking about their return through the summer and plans to bring them back for the colder months. They’re personal portions in small loaf tins. Anyone hoping to pick one up should check with the market about the seasonal schedule and availability.

Regular customers and a riddle to take home

Carrie credits the neighborhood’s support for the store’s success. Staff know many shoppers by name. Families with children, younger couples newly settled nearby and older residents who have shopped there since childhood all make up the customer base. Some visit once or twice a week. Others come daily, occasionally returning a second time for something they forgot.

A chalkboard behind the cash register gives those visits a little extra conversation. Kevin started the riddle tradition, and Carrie kept it. High school employees choose, write and change the riddles. Customers tell her about children carrying a question home to a parent or spouses passing it along after shopping. Some student employees arrive through those same neighborhood connections, as customers’ children or friends of other employees.

Local food and gifts share the shelves

The grocery selection reflects Carrie’s interest in local producers and products customers won’t find everywhere. Amazing Grains bread is a particular favorite. Cheesy Eddie’s supplies desserts including cheesecakes, carrot cakes and cookies filled with cheesecake filling. Her sourcing grows from years working in food, research, visits to the public market and conversations with makers who approach her.

Food isn’t the whole selection. Cutting boards, candles, pottery and fidget toys made by a young maker on a 3D printer give shoppers options for a small gift. Carrie said she sells some of these goods without making money on them, helping their makers get known. Her aim is practical: someone stopping for dinner ingredients can also find something to bring to a friend’s house or birthday.

The work behind a quick shopping trip

A short visit for dinner depends on decisions customers may never see. Carrie described rising costs across meat, groceries, energy, insurance, payroll and credit card processing. Local suppliers face higher ingredient costs too. She tries to balance what the store needs to earn with prices that won’t drive customers away.

Delivery requirements make that balancing act harder. Minimum orders can push a small store to buy more than it needs, creating questions about storage and waste. Carrie said her regular grocery deliveries had shifted from every two weeks to once a month, requiring her to predict demand for staples and account for holiday shopping.

Her response includes being direct with customers when a product is difficult to obtain. She explains supplier problems and looks for alternatives instead of leaving people to assume she simply hasn’t ordered something. A staff she enjoys working with and customers she wants to serve help her keep going.

Planning a holiday meal starts with a conversation

Holiday orders extend that personal service. Carrie described Thanksgiving preorders for fresh, uncooked turkeys, pies and Amazing Grains bread, plus plans for Christmas rib roast orders. The market’s butcher can also discuss requests for different cuts or preparation. Contact the market directly for current preorder options, sizes, deadlines and pickup arrangements.

Mary’s errands led Mark and Duffy to a place that made their ordinary evenings easier. For another neighbor, the reason to stop might be bread, a gift or a question for the butcher. R’s Market is at 2294 Monroe Avenue, between Twelve Corners and the 590 interchange. Start with what you need for dinner, and leave a moment for the riddle.

Stay Connected

Receive Email Updates

Subscribe to our email list and receive new episode updates and more.